Turkey has changed its policy toward aiding the Kurdish people against the Islamic State. It has announced that it is willing to allow the Iraqi Kurds to use Turkish territory to fight the IS. The decision is a curious one: it will allow the Iraqi Kurds, but not the Syrian or Turkish Kurds to be resupplied by the US. The Iraqi Kurds are regarded as politically different from the Kurds that have been fighting for greater autonomy in Turkish politics. The characterization is probably an accurate one at this point in time, but one cannot help but believe that the war against the IS will undoubtedly remind all Kurds of their common interests. One suspects that intense US pressure on Turkey–not the fine distinctions between the different Kurdish groups–is the principal reason for the change in policy.
If you wish to see a Kurdish parody of the IS that appeared on television, go to this link which is maintained by the Middle East Media Research Institute:
Deforestation is a serious global environmental problem. The number of forests that have been eliminated due to industrialization has been staggering, and there are only three tropical rainforests left in the world: in Brazil, in Central Africa, and in Indonesia. Brazil has launched a major effort to stop the process of deforestation, and it has been relatively successful. However, its rate of deforestation is beginning to rise and the country needs to rethink and recalibrate its efforts to preserve its rainforest.
Iran has set a deadline of 24 November to secure a deal with the P5+1 on the issue of its nuclear program. It was reported today that Iran has taken steps to further comply with some of the conditions established to obtain a deal. It has diluted part of its refined uranium stocks to the level of 2% enriched uranium, a level far below that necessary to build an atomic bomb (which requires enrichment of about 95% to start a chain reaction). The move is a sign that Iran is eager to make a deal, but it remains to be seen whether the P5+1 will be satisfied with the progress.
There has been an interesting development in the protests in Hong Kong. Hong Kong leader CY Leung has made the charge that “external forces” are involved in the protests. There were no specific details to the accusation, but it is a similar charge to that made by Russia after the protests in Kiev forced President Yanukovich to flee the country. We have no evidence that Leung’s fears are justified, but the accusation is often made against civil protests in order to delegitimize the protest movement as not being authentic. Meanwhile, violence continues to escalate in Hong Kong.
Sweden is searching its coast for what it suspects is a Russian submarine near the waters off Stockholm. The Swedes have received visual clues (see the photo) and intercepted Russian conversations on what is usually an emergency-only radio frequency. Submarines often patrol coastlines but if this photo (and it was one of three shot by three different observers) is actually of a Russian submarine, it clearly is in Swedish territorial waters. Both Sweden and Finland have recently reported harassing behavior in the air and on the sea by the Russians, and neither country is willing to ignore behavior that may signal aggressive intent. Right now, the suspicion is that the submarine may be experiencing mechanical trouble which would be an embarrassment to the Russian Navy.
I do not usually post purely opinion pieces, but Anne Applebaum of the Washington Post has written a short essay on an important question: whether the behavior of the US and NATO has provoked Russian President Putin to take such aggressive actions in east and central Europe. She ignores important Western actions in the Balkans in the 1990s, but she does list a large number of conciliatory actions taken by the West to encourage Russian support for preserving the Post-Cold War world order.
The Economist has published a very intelligent, substantive, and sobering analysis of the likely evolution of the Ebola outbreak in West Africa. When reading the article, one needs to maintain a clear framework: the current outbreak may become truly catastrophic, but only if the world fails to take the necessary steps to help out countries which lack the medical, economic, and political infrastructure to deal with the crisis. The world needs to understand that if everyone is to be protected from this virus, we need to treat the outbreak in West Africa with the same urgency and dedication as if the outbreak were in our own backyards. In this circumstance, everyone is a next-door neighbor.
Tensions are rising in Jerusalem as disputes have arisen over Muslim access to the al Aqsa Mosque. Israelis hold the Temple Mount (the area outlined in blue in the photograph below) as sacred; Muslims regard the mosque built on the Temple Mount as sacred. The only part of King Solomon’s Temple that remains is known as the Western Wall. Palestinian President Abbas gave a speech in which he called upon Fatah to protect the right of Muslims to enter the mosque, after Israel restricted Muslim access so that Israelis could visit the mosque. Any controversy over these sites are potentially very dangerous.
The three week battle between the Hong Kong authorities and student protesters has regained momentum as the protesters regained parts of the city from which the police had evicted them earlier. The back-and-forth struggle has been taking place against the backdrop of negotiations that can only be described as fitful. Both sides seem to be hardening their positions even as it is clear that both sides wish to avoid an outbreak of bloodshed. It is very difficult to see how this dispute will be resolved.
The US has experienced a steady worsening of income distribution over the last 40 years, but it is hardly alone. Income inequality seems to be a byproduct of both globalization and technological change, and virtually every country in the world has also seen inequality increase. China is a very interesting case: it has been without question the most remarkable case of poverty reduction in the history of the modern global economy. Over 660 million people have been lifted out of poverty in China over the last thirty years. Yet, at the same time, China’s incomes have gone from one of the world’s most equal distribution to a distribution that is worse than in the US. The Chair of the US Federal Reserve, Janet Yellen, highlighted the significance of income inequality in the US in a speech to the Boston Federal Reserve Bank:
The extent of and continuing increase in inequality in the United States greatly concern me. The past several decades have seen the most sustained rise in inequality since the 19th century after more than 40 years of narrowing inequality following the Great Depression. By some estimates, income and wealth inequality are near their highest levels in the past hundred years, much higher than the average during that time span and probably higher than for much of American history before then. It is no secret that the past few decades of widening inequality can be summed up as significant income and wealth gains for those at the very top and stagnant living standards for the majority. I think it is appropriate to ask whether this trend is compatible with values rooted in our nation’s history, among them the high value Americans have traditionally placed on equality of opportunity
Of course, some would have us believe that income inequality is not an issue:
Tomorrow will mark the anniversary of the Russian sale of Alaska to the United States in 1867. The US bought Alaska for 2 cents an acre from Russia, which was afraid it could not hold on to the territory after the expenses of the Crimean War. The dynamics were roughly equivalent to the US purchase of the Louisiana Territory from France, when Napoleon needed money for his wars in Europe and because the slave revolt in Haiti led by Toussaint L’Overture persuaded him that the French presence in the Western Hemisphere was too precarious. In both of these cases, the US added significant territory because of wars in other areas of the world.
Six months ago, the Islamic group, Boko Haram, kidnapped 200 school girls from the town of Chibok in the northeast of Nigeria. Today, the Nigerian government announced that it had made a deal with the group for the release of the girls. We do not yet know the details of the deal, nor has Boko Haram confirmed the deal. If true, however, the deal would be a tremendous victory for the government of Goodluck Jonathan. It follows the victory that the Nigerian government attained as the World Health Organization prepares to declare it and Senegal as Ebola-free.
The rise of the Islamic State has highlighted the tense relationship between Turkey and its Kurdish citizens. For a long time, there were some Kurdish groups that waged a low-level war against Turkey in pursuit of their dreams of an independent Kurdish state. Over time, there have been limited steps by both sides to forge a less confrontational relationship. Nonetheless, balancing the demands of Kurdish independence or greater autonomy against the idea of Turkish territoriality and sovereignty has been very difficult. One would think that having a common enemy–the Islamic State–would make both sides move closer together. That result may eventually come about, but the path to reconciliation has been fraught with difficulties.
There have been many horrific news reports of the behavior of members of the Islamic State that largely corroborate the mentality of a group that videotapes gruesome beheadings. Many of the reports, however, refer to the IS behavior toward non-Muslim women, but many of those reports are unverifiable. Speigel was able to talk with a young Yazidi woman who was held captive for nine days before escaping from the IS. Unfortunately, her story is consistent with all the worst fears about the IS.
The soccer match between Albania and Serbia had to be called off because of violence that broke out between the two teams and their fans. The relationship between the two countries have been quite bad since Kosovo declared its independence six years ago. The Serbs regard Kosovo as a sacred territory to Serbian nationalism, yet the population of Kosovo is, like Albania, overwhelmingly Muslim. The political hostility between the two states infects virtually every part of the Balkans and is a major factor in Russia-US relations as well.
Violence has broken out in the Hong Kong protests, but it is not clear exactly who is responsible. The police tried to remove some of the barricades, but men without uniforms assaulted several of the protesters. It seems as if the central government wants the protests to end, but is looking for a different ending than that of Tienanmen Square in 1989. The protesters and the government are both seeking some sort of resolution, but neither side knows how far it wishes to go. I suspect, however, that Beijing will not permit the protests to continue much longer.
Saudi Arabia has sentenced a prominent Shia cleric to death for his role in anti-government demonstrations two years ago. An estimated 10-15% of the Saudi population is Shia and that population is mostly concentrated in the oil-rich eastern sections of the country. The Saudis have grown increasingly nervous about the Shia minority in the Kingdom, and it is likely that the death sentence may be commuted. If not, the Shia minority will undoubtedly become more concerned about its place in the Kingdom.
In an interview with a Serbian newspaper, Russian President Putin made a highly provocative statement that is not being reported in much of the US press. His statement–“We hope that our partners will realize the futility of attempts to blackmail Russia and remember what consequences discord between major nuclear powers could bring for strategic stability”–is an unusual one in that it references nuclear weapons. Typically, such references are not made explicitly since people tend to get quite nervous when nukes are mentioned (for good reason).
Credit Suisse has published its annual report on global wealth, and the report has both good and bad news. The good news is that the creation of wealth has been robust: “…it seems likely that personal wealth has recently been rising at the fastest rate ever recorded.” The report estimates that personal wealth reached $263 trillion in 2013. The bad news is that wealth has grown considerably faster than income. The ratio of wealth to income has reached levels that mimic the levels just before the Great Depression. The report notes that ” abnormally high wealth income ratios have always signaled recession in the past.” Europe and North America together account for 67.1% of all the personal wealth in the world. Since income is a better determinant of spending than is wealth, the growing concentration of wealth/income ratios should signal a problem of lack of demand in the market.
The World Health Organization has estimated that, unless the outbreak is brought under control, the world could face 10,000 new infected cases a week by the end of this year. As of today, 4,447 people have died out of 8,914 cases. Most of those cases are in West Africa, but it is clear that the virus will spread to other countries in the world. There have been three cases in Germany and two in the US.
No matter what the issue is in world politics, there is always a back story. Sometimes we know the back story; sometimes we do not. There have been some secret documents released by the British government indicating that in the 1950s, Britain was thinking about granting Hong Kong independence, in much the same way it granted independence to Singapore. However, the Beijing government, under the leadership of Mao Zedong, squashed the plan, telling the British that it would be considered an unfriendly act. Obviously, the Beijing government wished to enjoy the economic benefits of Hong Kong, even at the expense of Hong Kong remaining a British colony.
The US Department of Defense issued a “roadmap” for how it will address the problem of climate change. [I will not ask any quiz questions from the report–it is too long] The Pentagon clearly regards the process as a national security threat. Its introduction to the document reads in part:
Among the future trends that will impact our national security is climate change. Rising global temperatures, changing
precipitation patterns, climbing sea levels, and more extreme weather events will intensify the challenges of global instability,
hunger, poverty, and conflict. They will likely lead to food and water shortages, pandemic disease, disputes over refugees and
resources, and destruction by natural disasters in regions across the globe.
In our defense strategy, we refer to climate change as a “threat multiplier” because it has the potential to exacerbate many of
the challenges we are dealing with today – from infectious disease to terrorism. We are already beginning to see some of these
impacts.
The report indicates that adapting to climate change is no longer a future consideration, but one that requires immediate changes in defense strategy.
The British Parliament has voted by 274 to 12 to ” ‘recognise the state of Palestine alongside the state of Israel’ as part of a ‘contribution to securing a negotiated two-state solution’.” It is a non-binding vote and the British Prime Minister has said that he will not act upon the motion. But the motion was sponsored by the Labour Party, suggesting that if it were to win the next election, it would change the policy toward Palestinian recognition. The vote follows the Swedish decision to recognize Palestine (which was an official change) and indicates a change in attitudes toward the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in Europe.
After the Beijing government broke off negotiations with the Hong Kong protesters, the people returned to the streets. There are rifts developing within the protest movement about the most effective strategy to move forward, but a large number believe that occupying the streets remains the best method. Unfortunately, there is a counter-protest movement developing, comprised of some people supportive of the Beijing position and frustrated with the protests but also some masked thugs who are resorting to physically attacking the protesters.
While the world is focusing on the tragedy unfolding in the city of Kobani, the Islamic State has made steady progress toward taking control of Iraq’s Anbar province. The province sprawls from the Jordanian border to the western suburbs of Baghdad, and it is primarily populated by Sunni Muslims, some of whom may be sympathetic to the IS. Iraqi authorities, however, are very concerned, and the leader of the province has called for the US to send ground troops to stem the tide. President Obama will not accommodate that request but it is ironic that Iraq was so insistent on the total withdrawal of US troops in 2012.
The global economy appears to be headed toward an unfortunate slowdown. Stock markets across the globe declined rather dramatically last week (the Dubai stock market declined 6% today) and the IMF issued a gloomy forecast. It is impossible to figure out what will happen next, but it does seem clear that national governments do not appear to have a plan to stimulate their economies. The economics editor of The Guardian has written an essay outlining his predictions for the future, and his outlook is not at all comforting.
Marina Silva has endorsed Aceio Neves for the upcoming Brazilian Presidential election. Silva came in third place, and there was some speculation that she would give her endorsement to Dilma Rousseff rather than the pro-business candidate Neves. Silva had asked Neves to support “land reform measures and better protections for indigenous communities as well as a demand that he drop plans to reduce from 18 to 16 the age at which minors can be tried as adults for serious crimes.” Neves has promised to act on the first two demands, but indicated that he will not change his position on the age at which juveniles can be tried as adults. Silva’s support increases the likelihood that Neves will win the election. We will see how Rousseff handles the end of the campaign.
In the face of an incredible tragedy, the real heroes of the Ebola crisis in West Africa are the local doctors and nurses who work selflessly to help the afflicted. They are aided by the group, Doctors Without Borders, which should also be regarded as heroic. The organization is fiercely independent and its mandate and method of operation completely repudiates the idea of the nation-state: it focuses only on the people who need medical assistance regardless of the political situation in a crisis. The New York Times has an article that gives a great background to the organization. And the US National Public Radio conducted an interview with some of the doctors working in West Africa. The last doctor interviewed is one of my oldest friends, Dr. Cameron Bopp, who was working in Monrovia, Liberia.
A Japanese medical study has indicated that male babies may be more susceptible to climate change than female babies. We have known for some time that female babies survive at a higher rate than male babies (even though the conception of males tends to be a little higher than for females). This study, however, suggests that temperature may have an adverse effect on male survival rates. It is far from a definitive study but we perhaps have another reason to question the effects of global warming on human society.
The UN is warning of a humanitarian disaster if the Islamic State seizes control of the town of Kobani (Ayn al-Arab in Arabic). Kurdish fighters are trying to prevent the takeover, but they are completely outgunned and Turkey refuses to open its borders so that the Kurdish fighters can be resupplied. The US has stepped up air strikes near the city, but the strikes are not likely to slowdown the IS advance. A UN official warned of a crisis roughly equivalent to the slaughter in the Bosnian town of Srebenica in 1995. In that incident thousands of innocents were slaughtered and the US was powerless to stop the violence. The Turkish refusal to allow aid to flow to the Kurds in Syria has led to increased violence within Turkey by Turkish Kurds.
World Politics News 